Deadbeat Dads Beware: Paternity Leave Must Be Reserved for ‘Responsible Husbands

Paternity Leave for All? Or Only the ‘Responsible’ Dads?”

South Africa just made a historic change: fathers are now entitled to four months of paternity leave, the same as mothers! 😲 Yes, you heard that right. Gone are the days of 10 measly days, which, let’s be honest, barely gave a man time to unpack the hospital bag, let alone bond with the baby.

This ruling came from the Constitutional Court of South Africa on October 3, 2025, after finding the previous system discriminatory. The Basic Conditions of Employment Act used to give mothers four months of maternity leave and fathers… well, 10 days. Clearly, that was ridiculously unfair. Now, parents—biological, adoptive, or through surrogacy—can share four months and ten days of parental leave, promoting equality in childcare.

Sounds amazing, right? And it is! But, as with all internet news, the comment sections did not disappoint. Some people made jokes about having multiple kids just to get more leave. Others raised a serious point: This law should only applied to married men/couples.

I found myself agreeing more than I expected. Here’s why:

1. Honoring commitment matters. Married men, whether they paid Lobola, had a white wedding, or a court wedding, usually show a certain level of responsibility toward their family. If you’re married and had a baby inside the marriage, the likelihood of using paternity leave responsibly is higher.

2. Reducing exploitation. Deadbeat fathers—or men who aren’t committed—could take advantage of this law if there are no boundaries. Limiting the leave to married men might reduce this risk.

3. Family stability. Giving leave to fathers in committed relationships helps bonding and co-parenting, which benefits the child, the parents, and even society.

But there’s the flip side: what about single mothers and fathers? Women who are unmarried still need their maternity leave, and excluding unmarried men might feel unfair. Life isn’t always neat especially when it comes to making bad choices, and families come in many forms.

Here’s where I personally stand: married men should get priority for paternity leave, not because unmarried men are bad, but because commitment usually increases responsibility. And yes, maternity leave should be at least nine months—after all, that’s how long the baby grew in the mother’s womb, and recovery plus bonding takes time. Fathers getting four months is a great start, but mothers deserve longer.

At the end of the day, this law is a huge step toward fairness, but it opens a debate: fairness vs. responsibility, rights vs. exploitation. And that’s the interesting part—because sometimes, the law can’t solve everything, but it can guide how we take care of our families (most of the times).

Sources & Facts:

Ruling Date: October 3, 2025

Implemented by: Constitutional Court of South Africa

Previous Law: Basic Conditions of Employment Act – 4 months maternity, 10 days paternity

New Law: 4 months + 10 days shared parental leave for both parents (biological, adoptive, or surrogate)

© 2025 The Dreamer’s Pause. All rights reserved.