By: The Girl Behind The Dreamer’s Pause
Let’s talk. Seriously. Because I’m tired.
Tired of the patterns. Tired of the selective outrage. Tired of people jumping on the “racism” bandwagon without watching the full video or checking the facts. And most of all? I’m tired of Black folks defending every single Black person—even when they are clearly in the wrong.
The latest case? William McNeil Jr., a Black college student in Jacksonville, Florida. Dreadlocks. Red shirt. Biology major. Band member. And the star of a now-viral video where he appears to be assaulted by police.
That video blew up. People were furious. It looked like just another case of police brutality. The student posted a clip showing officers breaking his car window, yanking him out, and striking him. And instantly, he became “another Black victim.”
But then I watched Officer Brandon Tatum’s breakdown. I saw the full bodycam footage. And everything changed.
🚨 What Really Happened
McNeil was pulled over for driving without headlights in rainy weather. Florida law requires headlights when it's raining—even if it’s bright outside. He also wasn’t wearing his seatbelt when police first approached.
Let’s talk about how calm and firm those officers were.They approached his locked vehicle and repeatedly instructed him to exit, offering him multiple verbal commands to exit the vehicle. He ignored them. He stalled. He locked his door. He demanded a supervisor, thinking that somehow excused him from following lawful commands.
He only switched on his phone camera when the second or third officer arrived at his window—just in time to frame the police as the aggressors. Strategic, right? What followed was a standard window break using an open hand strike, not a closed fist. That “fist to the face” everyone keeps shouting about? False. It was a window strike, and anyone who’s watched the real footage knows it.
The footage also showed McNeil resisting even after being removed. And guess what else they found? Drugs in his pocket, a suspended license and a large "12 inch" knife in his car. Which explains why he was resisting the arrest.
But none of that was in the footage he posted.
🎭 Performance Over Truth
This wasn’t just a misunderstanding. This was manipulation.
He filmed what he wanted us to see. Cropped out the parts where he refused lawful orders. Cut out the resisting. Cut out the knife. Cut out the drugs. He posted a tailor-made narrative to get sympathy, likes, and blind support. And people fell for it.
The saddest part? Black folks jumped to defend him the moment it went viral. Not because he was right. Not because they saw the full video. But because he was Black.
I say this as a Black person myself: that’s dangerous. That’s exhausting. That’s Black fatigue.
🧩 A Pattern We Need to Break
This isn’t the first time.
Remember Karmelo Anthony? No, not the athlete. The murderer. He killed a teenage boy, and still people backed him.
Or Sade Perkins— who was openly racist to kids who drowned at a campus event. And yet, people still made a GoFundMe for her. Sure, it was only a few hundred dollars, but the principle is the problem.
It’s the same script every time:
1. Someone Black does something wrong.
2. They play the victim online.
3. People scream racism.
4. They ignore all evidence that contradicts the story.
I’m done. You should be too.
🔥 The Real Consequences
You know who suffers?
The real victims. The ones who actually experience police brutality. The ones who deserve justice. Because when we defend every liar, manipulator, and lawbreaker who just happens to be Black, we destroy our credibility.
Racism is real. Police abuse exists. But if we keep crying wolf every time someone films a one-sided story, then when the real wolves come? No one will listen.
And honestly, those police officers? I feel sorry for them. They acted with restraint. They followed protocol. They were cautious. And now they’re being demonized. Because one black student wanted to go viral.
🤯 Wake Up Call
If you’re defending McNeil after watching the full bodycam, you’re not fighting for justice. You’re being willfully blind.
So stop yelling “fist” when it was clearly a palm push. Stop screaming racism without context. Stop defending people based on race alone.
I’m Black. But I’m not going to support foolishness.
Call it what you want. But truth is truth. And in this case? The so-called “victim” was the one who escalated everything.
I know this post will ruffle feathers. Good. Feathers need ruffling when birds are flying in the wrong direction.
✊🏾 Final Word
To every Black person reading this:
> Holding your own accountable is not betrayal.
It’s integrity.
📚 References
© 2025 The Dreamer’s Pause. All rights reserved.
