Tuesday, November 17, 2026

FROM CHIDIMMA TO A SCRAP-METAL CROWN: IS MISS SOUTH AFRICA OKAY?

MISS SOUTH AFRICA 2026: WAS THE CROWN MADE DURING THE COMMERCIAL BREAK?






There are certain moments in a beauty pageant that are supposed to be unforgettable. The final walk, the announcement of the winner, the emotional reactions, the flowers, the photographs and, of course, that beautiful moment when the crown is placed on the winner's head.

It's the moment every contestant dreams about. After weeks, sometimes months, of preparation, one woman finally gets to hear those magical words: You are Miss South Africa!

But I have a feeling that people watching Miss South Africa 2026 will remember something else entirely.

Not the dresses. Not the performances. Not even the winner's reaction.

The crown. And, unfortunately, the dress too.

South Africa, please tell me we all saw the same thing.

I have been trying to understand the creative direction behind this year's crowning moment, and honestly, I'm struggling. I don't even know which one to discuss first. The crown or the outfit?

Let's start with the crown.


[Tiyani on top~ Credited by: Ilaria Finizio / AFP via Getty Images. Photo at the bottom credited by: no individual photographer named.]



Because WHAT WAS THAT?

I'm sorry, but that thing looked like it was made by a six-year-old who had just discovered metal, glue and a pair of scissors. And before anyone comes for me, I genuinely cannot imagine an adult designer looking at that finished product and saying, "Perfect! This is exactly what our new Miss South Africa should wear."

Where were the crystals? Where were the diamonds? Where were the beautiful stones that make you look at a crown and immediately think, THAT IS A QUEEN?

Even artificial stones would have helped. We were not asking for the Crown Jewels. We were asking for something that looked like it belonged at a national beauty pageant.

And that tie at the back? A TIE? At Miss South Africa?

Haibo! Even SHEIN has better options. I'm convinced somebody could have opened an online shopping app, searched for ceremonial crowns and found something more glamorous before the finale was over.

But wait. Have we discussed the dress?

Because I watched the clips again, and I honestly think the dress made the situation worse.



[Tiyani Makamu's winning moment and stage photographs by Thapelo Morebudi.
Sowetan – Full photo gallery⁠.]



Tiyani Makamu is a beautiful woman, and I don't think anyone should take that away from her. Congratulations to her, by the way. But who advised her to wear that blue dress for her crowning moment?

It wasn't giving Miss South Africa. It was giving Sunday picnic. It was giving a lovely afternoon outing with friends, a blanket, some sandwiches and a bottle of juice.

A nice dress for the right occasion? Perhaps. But for the moment when you're being crowned Miss South Africa? I'm not convinced.

Imagine spending all that time preparing for a national beauty pageant, finally winning, and then your dress and crown look like they were selected by two completely different people who had never spoken to each other.

I almost started wondering whether Tiyani had a feeling about the crown beforehand. Maybe she knew something we didn't. Maybe she thought, let me not waste my best outfit because I don't know what they're bringing out tonight.

And I might have been a little more forgiving about the crown if the dress had been absolutely stunning. At least we could have said, well, the crown missed the assignment, but the queen's outfit saved the evening.

Unfortunately, both decided to disappoint us together.

Now, the organisation has explained that the crown was a temporary ceremonial design called Imbokodo, while a permanent crown is being developed. The new design is expected to involve young South African designers and public participation. Beautiful idea. We love supporting local talent. We love involving young designers. But surely, there was a better way to introduce this idea?


[Tiyani's crowning photograph:
Photo: Timothy Bernard / ANA Studios. ]




Here's what makes the situation even more interesting. The previous Mowana crown, designed by Nungu Diamonds, was still an option. Nungu Diamonds reportedly offered the organisation permission to use it for the finale, despite the sponsorship agreement not being renewed.

The organisation did not take up the offer.

Now, I want to be a little fair to the organisation here.

South Africans are not exactly the easiest audience to please. Let's be honest.


[Credited: unknown/ Facebook fan]


If they had brought back the previous crown, somebody would have been on social media asking why the new queen was wearing an old queen's crown. If they had bought a temporary crown, somebody would probably have investigated it, discovered it wasn't an expensive original design and dragged them for buying a fake. And if they had presented no crown at all, well, we all know what would have happened.

There would have been another national investigation on X.

So, I can understand that the organisation was probably in a difficult position. They wanted something new, they wanted to avoid criticism and they wanted to introduce a different direction.

But surely, there is a balance?

Why not announce beforehand that there would be no traditional crown for this year's finale because a new permanent design was being developed? That would at least have prepared the audience. People would still complain, obviously. Somebody would always find something to say. But at least the organisation would have been transparent.

Instead, we were introduced to Imbokodo, and I think the name deserves a much better-looking crown.

And the crown wasn't even the only thing people were complaining about.

A lot of South Africans have also criticised the overall production, with some describing it as one of the cheapest Miss South Africa shows they've ever watched on television. From the presentation to the styling and the general production, people were questioning what had happened to the glamour of the competition.

At this point, I almost want to ask whether somebody cut the budget and forgot to inform the audience. And just when the internet was having a field day, Takealot joined the conversation with its own crown-related advertising humour.

Takealot! A whole online shopping platform!

Imagine your national beauty pageant becoming a marketing opportunity for a retailer. Somewhere, a marketing team saw that crown and probably said, "Thank you for the free campaign material." I mean, business is business, but that is embarrassing. But perhaps we shouldn't be too surprised. Miss South Africa has had quite a few dramatic moments over the past three years.


Let's take a little trip backwards.



[Left side: Chidimma Adetshina / Instagram. Right side: Mia le Roux/ Crowning photograph: Marco Longari,AFP.]


In 2024, Chidimma Adetshina's participation became a national controversy. Born in Soweto to a Nigerian father and a South African mother of Mozambican heritage, she faced questions about her nationality and family background. A Home Affairs investigation raised serious allegations involving her mother's identity documents. Chidimma eventually withdrew from Miss South Africa, went to Nigeria, won Miss Universe Nigeria and represented the country at Miss Universe.

Mia le Roux eventually won Miss South Africa 2024, but even her victory attracted criticism from some South Africans who questioned whether a white woman should represent the country.

Then came 2025. Qhawekazi Mazaleni won Miss South Africa, while Mellisa Nayimuli was separately selected to represent South Africa at Miss Universe. Her Ugandan and Xhosa heritage also became a talking point online.


[Right side: Mellisa Nayimuli – Miss Universe South Africa 2025, photograph: Mohan Raj, Left side: Qhawekazi Mazaleni's photographer: Oupa Mokoena / Independent Newspapers.]



Honestly, does this competition ever get to enjoy a peaceful year? But there's something about the Chidimma situation that makes this year's crown controversy even more interesting.


[Chidimma's Crowning moment in Miss Universe Nigeria,Photographer: Benson Ibeabuchi / AFP.
Getty Images – Photograph 2168972160⁠.]



Remember how a lot of South Africans mocked the Nigerian pageant after Chidimma went there? People had plenty to say about the production, the presentation and, yes, the crown. There were jokes about how the Nigerian pageant looked, and some South Africans were certainly enjoying themselves. Suddenly, Nigeria's competition was being used as an example of what a beauty pageant shouldn't look like.

And now, look at this.

The same country whose people were laughing at another country's crown now has a crown that has become an international joke and an advertising opportunity for Takealot.

Not immediately, but surely, karma has found its way to the Miss South Africa conversation. I still believe the allegations involving Chidimma's family's identity documents deserved proper investigation. That's a separate issue. But the irony of watching our own national competition become the subject of similar mockery is something I cannot ignore.

Karma? I'll let South Africans decide that one.


[Tiyani Makamu/ Facebook]



Congratulations once again, Tiyani. I genuinely wish you a wonderful reign, and I hope you make South Africa proud on the international stage.

As for the Miss South Africa organisation, the queen got her crown. South Africa got a comedy show. Takealot got free advertising. And the rest of us are still trying to understand the creative direction.


© 2026 The Dreamer’s Pause. All rights reserved.

No comments:

MY PARENTS SHOULD HAVE BEEN ARRESTED FOR WHAT THEY MADE ME DO AS A CHILD.

Imagine being promoted to deputy parent without applying for the position, receiving a salary or, more importantly, being given ...

Popular Posts